Skip to content
The Slice Guy mark

The Slice Guy

HistoryRecipesPlacesAward-winningStylesGuidesWatchPizza Products
Share a pieRecommend a place
HistoryRecipesPlacesAward-winningStylesGuidesWatchPizza Products
Share a pieRecommend a place
HistoryRecipesPlacesAward-winningStylesGuidesWatchPizza Products
Share a pieRecommend a place

United States

Pizza in Orange.

1 pizzerias on the board in Orange, United States. Editor picks and neighbor recs — all real shops.

Star Tavern in OrangeOrangeEditor

Star Tavern

Orange, United States

400 High Street, Orange, NJ 07050

Editor's pick

The Essex County bar pie. Thin, crisp, cut in squares, eaten in a booth.

New
Tavern

Bake Orange at home

A kit for the style this city actually eats — plus the pies to practice.

  • King Arthur 00 Pizza Flour

    Flour

    Check Amazon.com
  • Baking Steel Original

    Baking Steel

    Check Amazon.com
  • Cento Certified San Marzano Tomatoes

    Tomatoes

    Check Amazon.com
  • Low-Moisture Mozzarella

    Toppings

    Check Amazon.com
  • OXO Good Grips Pizza Wheel

    Pizza Cutter

    Check Amazon.com
  • Diamond Crystal Kosher Salt

    Salt

    Check Amazon.com
  • OXO Good Grips Kitchen Scale

    Scale

    Check Amazon.com

As an Amazon Associate, The Slice Guy earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and stock live on Amazon.

Pies in this style

Classic Cheese PizzaNew York

Classic Cheese Pizza

From New York

Sauce, mozzarella, that’s it. The pie Google still looks for every night.

New
More in New JerseyAll placesRecommend a place
The Slice Guy mark

The Slice Guy

A pizza blog — recipes, ovens, and shops worth the trip.

Start hereAward-winningGuidesWatchPizza ProductsRecipesPlaces
AboutPrivacyContactDisclaimer

As an Amazon Associate, The Slice Guy earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and stock live on Amazon. This is a pizza blog — not a restaurant.

© 2026 The Slice Guy